抖文 - What Did the Hundred Regiments Offensive Commanded by Peng Dehuai Really Accomplish 的评论
The Hundred Regiments Campaign: How Peng Dehuai Shook the Enemy with a Single ThunderAt exactly 8...
The fact that they could coordinate 105 regiments in 1940 is genuinely impressive. I'm wondering what the Japanese response was and whether this forced them to change their occupation strategy in North China. The article excerpt ends right before the good part!|
Excellent primary source material here. I'll be using this with my students – the specific date and scale make it concrete and real. Though I'll definitely need to supplement with casualty figures and strategic assessments.|
My grandfather fought in the Eighth Route Army during this period. I wish this article had more details about what it was like for regular soldiers, not just the grand strategy. What was their perspective?|
The writing is a bit too dramatic and romanticized for my taste. "Torn asunder"? "Shook the enemy with a single thunder"? I want facts and analysis, not poetry. Still curious about the actual numbers though.|
Peng Dehuai was a brilliant commander. The coordination required to synchronize attacks across such vast distances in 1940 without modern communications is almost unbelievable. This deserves way more attention in history classes than it gets.|
Wait, I have a question – what was the actual strategic outcome? The title asks what it "really accomplished" but the excerpt cuts off before explaining the results. Did it work or was it ultimately a failure?|
This is fascinating military history! I had no idea the scale was this massive – 105 regiments attacking simultaneously across multiple provinces. The dramatic opening really draws you in.|