抖文 - Why Was the Song Dynasty Economy So Prosperous Despite Military Weakness (960–1279) 的评论
type: channel
link: https://douwen.me/archives/641/
description: Why Was the Song Dynasty Economy So Prosperous Despite Military Weakness (960–1279)The Song Dynas...
items: OldTeacher_Jim
items: YoungScholar22
items: Dr_WangLi
items: CasualReader
items: SongDynastyNerd
items: HistoryBuff2847
items: GregoryH

OldTeacher_Jim
type: item
date: 2026-05-13T18:21:32+08:00
description: I've been teaching Chinese history for 30 years and this is still one of the most underappreciated aspects of the Song period. The irony is that their "weakness" actually made them culturally and intellectually the golden age of China. Would definitely recommend this article.|

YoungScholar22
type: item
date: 2026-05-13T15:33:17+08:00
description: Wait, so basically they chose trade over warfare? That's actually kind of genius when you think about it. Less resources wasted on armies = more money for commerce and development. Modern countries could learn from this lol|

Dr_WangLi
type: item
date: 2026-05-13T20:28:32+08:00
description: Excellent framing of the question. I would add that the Song Dynasty's weakness was partly geographic—surrounded by powerful neighbors—which forced them to innovate economically rather than militarily. The Jurchen invasions in 1127 were catastrophic but also pivotal to their economic restructuring.|

CasualReader
type: item
date: 2026-05-13T08:32:45+08:00
description: honestly kind of sad that they had to give up so much militarily to succeed economically. those treaties sound like they cost them a lot. makes you wonder if it was worth it?|

SongDynastyNerd
type: item
date: 2026-05-13T16:53:07+08:00
description: Finally someone addressing this paradox! The monetization of the economy and the shift toward maritime trade is absolutely key here. The Song literally invented so much of early modern capitalism.|

HistoryBuff2847
type: item
date: 2026-05-13T16:58:35+08:00
description: Great question, but I think the article is missing context about WHY they were weak militarily. Was it because they invested in trade instead of the military? Or were there other factors? Would love to see that explored.|

GregoryH
type: item
date: 2026-05-13T11:04:00+08:00
description: This is fascinating! I never realized the Song Dynasty was so economically advanced despite military struggles. Looking forward to reading the full article.|